“His Size Should Not Hold Him Back”: A c.1962 Scouting Report on Joe Morgan, Written Before He Signed

This is a handwritten scouting report on Joe Morgan from about 1962, on a 3" x 5" index card with “Morgan, Joe” at the top and “62” written at the upper edge. The scout’s notes read: “Cat like player - good hands,” “excellent stick and good base runner - needs to work on double play,” “Good all around athlete,” and “His size should not hold him back - Good bet in pro ball.” That last line is the most interesting. At 5-foot-7 and 160 pounds, Morgan was small, and it was a real concern. No team offered him a bonus out of Castlemont High School in Oakland, so he went to Oakland City College, a two-year school, where he caught the attention of scouts. The card was written while he was in college, in the year he turned pro, when a scout saw the tools and decided his size wouldn’t matter.

He was right. Houston Colt .45s scout Bill Wight signed Morgan on November 1, 1962, for $500 a month and a $3,000 bonus, and Morgan debuted on September 21, 1963. He went on to win two NL MVP awards (1975 and 1976) for the Big Red Machine, five Gold Gloves, and ten All-Star selections, and he finished with 268 home runs and 689 stolen bases. He was elected to the Hall of Fame in 1990 on the first ballot, and Bill James named him the best second baseman of all time. A scouting report written before any of it happened, with the same few notes (hands, bat, running, the double play) that a scout would write about any prospect, is a rare original look at a future Hall of Famer at the beginning. The card shows age toning but minimal wear and comes with a letter of provenance from Theresa Morgan.

Previous
Previous

1956 Duke Snider Contract

Next
Next

Minnie Minoso's Cuban Passport